Stoicism & Early Christianity

A Comprehensive primer on Stoic Philosophy and its complex relationship to early Christianity. Systematically and Chronologically translating all known Stoic texts, this collection introduces the reader to all of the original (mostly 13th century Latin) texts, their context, their Jewish reception and their relationship to early Christian practice, particularly Paul's engagement with the actual living Stoic religion (yes, religion- with temples and everything).

Why do Entrepreneur-minded Protestants ready daily pagan devotionals?
The popularity of Stoicism in the secular sphere is predictable- multiple waves of this have happened in Europe, and the Daily Stoic craze is just the latest iteration of re-purposed Stoicism being used as Self-Help. The first massive pop culture resurgence was during the Renaissance as scholars rediscovered classical texts, and Christian Aesthetics- as seen in the erasure of the Anchorite- declined as Protestantism transformed into Agnostic-Modernism. Humanists like Justus Lipsius, a leader of the so-called Neostoic movement, reintegrated Stoic ideals into Christian ethics, blending ancient philosophy with modern thought. Peter Paul Rubens, the Flemish Baroque painter, visually encapsulated this revival in works such as The Four Philosophers (1611–12), which depicted Lipsius alongside a bust of Seneca, which today remains the visualization of Stoicism. In Rubens’ day, cannibalized snippets of Stoic texts were popular as self-help guidance.

In the 20th and 21st centuries, Stoicism experienced another resurgence, adapted to modern psychological and self-help contexts. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) pioneers like Albert Ellis and Aaron Beck drew on Stoic principles to address emotional resilience, while authors like Ryan Holiday repackaged its teachings for personal development. This modern wave emphasizes mindfulness and emotional control, which is radically contrary to the actual teachings of Zeno's school. But why do Protestants read Pagan philosophers as if they are devotionals, and follow the Aesthetic practices of an ideology which Paul explicitly denounces in Acts? And this is part of a broad integration of Pagan thought into Christianity, including Manifesting & Astrology (Pantheism) and sometimes full-blow magic (the "word of faith" movement). The answer lies at least in part in the reformation's rejection of Holiness and by extension self-discipline, Aestheticism and Monasticism through the adoption of Sola Fide i.e. "Faith alone" Gnosticism, rending Christian practice without any ability or need to be applied. Hence, Paganism becomes a life-improvement mechanism to attempt to restore meaning through a flat and aimless aestheticism to a life which Protestant metaphysics has gutted. Schopenhauer notes the reason for this hybridization with Paganism:

The essence of Protestantism is individualism, which necessarily leads to subjectivism, and this, in turn, to the denial of objective truth.
Protestantism, by rejecting celibacy and actual asceticism in general, as well as its representatives, the saints, has become a blunted, or rather broken-off Christianity, lacking the pinnacle: it runs out into nothing.... by eliminating asceticism and its central point, the merit of celibacy, has actually already abandoned the innermost core of Christianity and is to that extent to be regarded as apostasy from it. This has become evident in our days in the gradual transition of Christianity into the flat rationalism, this modern Pelagianism,  the flat rationalism, this modern Pelagianism, which in the end boils down to a doctrine of a loving father who made the world, and who, if one only submits to his will in certain respects, will also provide for an even much prettier world afterward (the only complaint about which is that it has such a fatal entrance).
This may be a good religion for comfortable, married, and enlightened Protestant pastors: but it is not Christianity

Previous
Previous

Kaiser Konstantin, der Sündenbock